Correspondence with Geneseo re: repository policies

Being Brockport, we didn’t really have a lot of policies in place when we started the IR. So my answers will be a combination of policy and practice.

On whether submission is mandatory:

Our first thesis collection was the Environmental Science and Biology collection, which came out of a discussion with a professor, who was also chair of the graduate committee at the time. They started requiring their students to submit to them their thesis on CD, along with their print copies to be bound. The Education department came along next, and they were open to the idea of actually having the students submit their thesis to Digital Commons, and the advisor would do a final approval and it would be published. About a year into the repository initiative, the Graduate School submitted a proposal to the College Senate asking for it to be mandatory that theses that would normally be submitted to the library for binding, be submitted digitally to the IR. The department could still bind, if they wished but the IR was the primary depository. Has that been adhered to? Marginally. It continues to be an educational process, but I believe the 3 biggest departments comply.

On how we receive permission:

Our thesis collection is two pronged – retrospective and born-digital. The born-digital collection has a click through agreement that the student checks before they submit their thesis. Here is a link to the instruction guide (found in the sidebar of each collection) http://digitalcommons.brockport.edu/ehd_theses/submission_guide.pdf that we provide each department. It works the student through the process step by step, and shows a piece of the permission agreement. For our retrospective theses, we digitize and try and find emails to ask permission to upload. This tends to be time consuming, and I admit that I have many more theses digitized than I am currently able to upload, so I have put a moratorium on doing any more at this point. We have a Thesis Digitization Policy, based on University of South Florida’s listed on our website http://digitalcommons.brockport.edu/thesis_digitization_policy.pdf .

Creative work and other lessons learned:

As some of the original champions have retired or moved away, questions have arisen such as: we don’t want our students research published before we get a chance to publish (the sciences), or what about work that isn’t quite good enough to be in the IR, or what about if the student wants to publish in the future? So, just about a year ago, we started allowing embargos (one year automatic for EnvSci, and one year renewable for Bio). Some of the creative writers who gave permission have come back with individual requests (could I take this down – I think if Mrs. XXX read it, they might sue me for libel; I want to self-publish- it is allowed if it’s on the IR?) Those kinds of questions. I offer to provide a link in the metadata to their “published” book. English gives their graduates a choice of whether to submit or not, in fact, I’m not sure that they even tell them about it, to be honest.

Is it worth the time and effort?

I’m not sure which platform you are thinking about for your IR. We have been very happy with bepress and Digital Commons, but here’s my caveat: you will get out of it, what you are willing to put into it. If you look at the 5 IR’s in the http://suny.researchcommons.org/ , 3 of us started at about the same time. Only one of us has a full time IR manager and the difference in size of collections and number of downloads is noticeable. But, it depends on what your goals are for the IR. I consider Digital Commons a part of the Brockport marketing plan, and align my goals with the strategic goals of the college, and the strategic goals of the library.

I’m sorry, you ask a simple question, and I answer with an essay. Please let me know if there is anything else you need to know.

Kim

From: Allison Brown [mailto:browna@geneseo.edu]
Sent: Tuesday, October 27, 2015 12:17 PM
To: Myers, Kim
Subject: Question about Digital Commons

Hi Kim,

We were beginning a conversation about IRs with a faculty here at Geneseo, and I was wondering if I could ask some questions about your experiences with the digital repository at Brockport.

I noticed you have a fair amount of student theses and dissertations available through digital commons, and was wondering if you had any insight into how individual departments handle this. For example, is it mandatory, and do the students sign a release? 

We are also curious if any of the theses you host are creative writing, and if so, what were the discussions leading up to including these types of student work in the repository. Our faculty member is advocating to include all types of student work, but has heard some arguments against providing open access to unpublished student creative work, and I was curious whether this was a conversation you had at Brockport while setting up policies for Digital Commons. 

Any insight you have would be helpful!